Grand Theft Auto VI debuted with a Metascore of 99 on November 18, 2026, tying The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1998) for the highest-rated game in Metacritic’s history. The score arrived on the strength of 100 critic reviews ahead of the game’s November 19 launch.
The Weighted Calculus Behind the Score
Metacritic converts every critic and user review into a percentage score, either by translating a provided rating or through subjective editorial assessment when a review lacks an explicit score. Those percentages are then fed into a weighted average adjusted for the critic’s popularity, reputation, and review volume. The result is the Metascore, a single number intended to reflect the critical consensus more precisely than a simple mean.
The methodology has drawn scrutiny. The site assigns scores to unrated reviews via subjective editorial judgment, a practice critics argue injects opacity into a system marketed as objective. The platform has also faced allegations of third-party score manipulation and user review bombing conducted through sock puppet accounts.
From Independent Launch to Fandom Ownership
Jason Dietz, Marc Doyle, and Julie Doyle Roberts created Metacritic in 1999 and launched it in January 2001, seeking to cover a broader range of media than the movie-focused Rotten Tomatoes. The site changed hands repeatedly: acquired by CNET in 2005, absorbed into CBS Corporation, sold to Red Ventures in 2020, and finally purchased by Fandom, Inc. in 2022. Each transition left the core aggregation model intact while expanding the platform’s commercial reach.
The Exclusive 99 Club
A score of 99 is a historic rarity. Before GTA 6, only The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time held that mark, setting the benchmark in 1998. The new entry ties that record, placing Rockstar’s latest in a category of one other title across more than two decades of aggregation.
Rockstar’s Ascending Trajectory
Rockstar Games has treated the Metascore as a reliable indicator of its own consistency. Grand Theft Auto IV peaked at 98, the studio’s previous high watermark. Grand Theft Auto V settled at 97, matching Grand Theft Auto III. San Andreas and Vice City both sit at 95. GTA 6’s 99 represents a marginal but symbolically significant step above the developer’s own ceiling.
Market Signal and Publisher Leverage
The Wall Street Journal reported in 2007 that Metacritic influences game sales and video game publisher stocks, noting that Wall Street tracks scores as an early indicator of commercial performance before sales data arrives. Publishers have used Metascores to determine developer bonuses; Obsidian Entertainment missed a royalty payout for Fallout: New Vegas when its 84 fell one point short of Bethesda’s 85 threshold.
Fandom Turns the Score Into a Sweepstakes
Fandom and Metacritic ran a contest for U.S. residents to guess GTA 6’s Metascore for cash prizes up to $500. Entries closed November 17, with winners drawn around November 25. The median fan prediction clustered at 98, one point shy of the actual debut figure.
Sources
- Metacritic
- GTA 6 Gets a 99 in Early Metacritic Review Scores
- GTA 6 contest could see you net $500 just for guessing the game's Metacritic score
- Grand Theft Auto VI Achieves 99 Metacritic Score, Matching 1998's The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time – PlayStation Universe
Photo: Towfiqu barbhuiya / Unsplash (Unsplash License)





