The review embargo on Grand Theft Auto 6 lifted on Wednesday, and the game has debuted with a 99 Metascore on Metacritic, tying the 1998 Nintendo 64 version of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for the highest rating in the site’s history. The score is based on more than 150 reviews across both the PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X versions, a sample size that dwarfs the 22 critic reviews underpinning Ocarina of Time’s identical mark.
The Technical Reality of the Metascore
Metacritic’s influence stems from its attempt to quantify critical consensus. The site aggregates reviews from a curated list of publications, converts each outlet’s native scale — stars, letter grades, scores out of ten or one hundred — into a standardised 0-100 metric, and then applies a weighted average. The weighting is the technical reality that matters: not every outlet counts equally. Metacritic assigns higher influence to publications it deems more prestigious or consistent, a proprietary formula that means a 90 from a top-tier outlet moves the needle more than a 90 from a smaller site. The resulting Metascore is colour-coded: 81-100 signals “universal acclaim,” 61-80 “generally favourable,” and below that, the shades of mixed or negative reception.
Historical Benchmarks and the Rockstar Trajectory
The 99 represents a new ceiling for Rockstar Games. The studio’s previous high watermark was Grand Theft Auto IV’s 98 in 2008. Grand Theft Auto V, released 13 years ago, settled at 97, matching Grand Theft Auto III. San Andreas and Vice City both sit at 95. Red Dead Redemption 2, until this week a fixture in Metacritic’s all-time top 10 with a 97, has been displaced by its stablemate. The trajectory is clear: Rockstar’s mainline open-world titles have clustered in the mid-to-high 90s for two decades, but GTA 6 is the first to breach the 98 barrier.
How the Score Drives the Machine
For a title launching at $80 for the standard edition and $100 for the ultimate version, the Metascore functions as a financial instrument. Publisher Take-Two Interactive and Rockstar had already reportedly sold more than 17 million copies ahead of launch, generating $1.65 billion in revenue according to Sensor Tower data cited by Polygon. That pre-order velocity is the product of brand power, certainly, but the 99 validates the expenditure for the marginal buyer and reassures retailers and platform holders. Developer reputation, already sterling, calcifies further; a 99 makes the “Rockstar standard” a measurable benchmark for the industry. Player expectations, meanwhile, are now anchored to a number that suggests perfection. The eight Game of the Year nominations at The Game Awards, announced Tuesday before the embargo lifted, confirm the awards-season machinery is already calibrated to this score.
The Detail That Matters: Sample Size and Platform Parity
As ever, the detail that matters is not the integer but the distribution. A 99 derived from 150-plus reviews across two platforms — both the PS5 and Series X versions hold the same score — indicates a stability that a smaller sample cannot. It suggests the technical performance under the hood is consistent across the current-gen hardware split, a non-trivial achievement for an open-world game of this density. The original Ocarina of Time’s 99 rests on 22 reviews from a different critical era; GTA 6’s rests on a modern, expanded critic corpus. The record is now shared, but the statistical confidence behind Rockstar’s number is an order of magnitude higher.
Grand Theft Auto 6 officially launches on November 19.
Sources
- ‘GTA 6’ Earns Rave Reviews and Lands 99 Metacritic Score, Tying for Highest-Rated Game of All Time
- GTA 6 Sets New Record As Highest-Rated Video Game of All Time
- GTA 6 Gets a 99 in Early Metacritic Review Scores
Photo: Cian Ginty (Attribution)





